Case study · Fratello Coffee Roasters

A Calgary roaster's store, rebuilt after a breach

From August 2022 to launch night in October 2023, we refreshed Fratello's shop, then after a breach moved it to Shopify, with subscriptions, rewards, affiliates and volume pricing built in. Three years on, they show up on Google's page one for 5.5 times as many searches as the year before we started.

5.5×page-one Google results in Canada and the US

A bag of Fratello Godfather Espresso

Godfather Espresso, their best seller

01 · August 2022

The 2022 refresh

In August 2022 Fratello asked for a refresh: new type and colour, video, clearer product shots, a new footer, and tidier menus with Analog Café under their story. In the first three weeks after it went live, revenue and bags sold were both up more than 10%.

Fast, easy and professional… on budget and on time.

Google review, November 2022
Revenue and bags sold in the first 21 days after the refresh, against the 21 days before. Fully paid orders only.

02 · April 2023

The 2023 breach

In April 2023 a fake admin account on the old WordPress site added payment options meant to send customers' money somewhere else. It happened three times in a month. Each fix meant rolling the shop back, and every rollback broke the order sync with shipping and accounting.

Fratello had wanted to move to Shopify for a while. After April, it couldn't wait.

  • Card paymentsactive
  • Shipping ratesactive
  • Extra card checkoutadded by an unknown admin
  • Pay by bank transferadded by an unknown admin
  • Pay with cryptoadded by an unknown admin
The old shop's payment settings, as the breach left them. Illustration.

03 · Summer 2023

The move to Shopify

Shopify meant almost every address on the site would change. We moved the order history, customer accounts, around 190 blog posts and 57 collections, and pointed every old address at its new one, so old links and search results still work.

We also wired the store to their shipping and accounting systems, added US shipping and US-dollar pricing, and recorded training videos so the team could run it themselves.

  1. /product-category/coffee/→/collections/coffee
  2. /product/godfather-espresso/→/products/godfather
  3. /coffee-processing-methods-explained/→/blogs/blog/coffee-processing-methods-explained
  4. /my-account/→/account
  5. /cafe-services/→/pages/wholesale
Some old addresses and where they now point.

04 · Subscribe & Save

Subscriptions and delivery schedules

Subscriptions became the program Fratello leans on most. Customers pick their coffee and a schedule, every two to five weeks, and change, skip or pause it themselves from their own account. Volume pricing stacks on top, so a bigger standing order costs less per bag.

Today, "Subscribers save 20% on every order" is the first line on Fratello's homepage.

One quarter of deliveries for each schedule a subscriber can choose. Illustration.

05 · The menu

What else the new store added

Around the subscriptions we built rewards, an affiliate program, volume pricing, wholesale applications, and review and follow-up emails.

  • Fratello RewardsPoints for every order and review, with Bronze, Silver and Gold tiersbuilt
  • Affiliate programPartners and creators earn 10, 12 or 15% with their own codesbuilt
  • Buy more, save moreVolume pricing that stacks with a subscriptionbuilt
  • WholesaleApplications and café consultations for businessesbuilt
  • Reviews, email and gift cardsReview requests, welcome and thank-you emails, gift cardsbuilt

06 · 30 October 2023

Launch night

The new store went live on a Monday evening at the end of October, nearly four weeks before Black Friday. We kept the old site as an archive in case anything had been missed.

This website is a jewel man! You have done such an incredible job. I really do hope you feel proud about what has been created.

Fratello, the morning after launch

07 · November 2023

First Black Friday on Shopify

In the 30 days up to Cyber Monday 2023, revenue was 47% higher than the same 30 days in 2022. Fratello's promotions drove the sales, and the new store kept up.

+47%revenue, 30 days up to Cyber Monday, against 2022

Revenue in the 30 days up to Cyber Monday 2023, against the same 30 days in 2022. Both years ran Black Friday promotions.

08 · Search

When Fratello came to us, the old shop had lost three quarters of its page-one Google results in eighteen months. The refresh and our SEO work in 2023 turned that around. Rankings dipped over the winter after the move to Shopify and were back on trend by May 2024. Today Fratello shows up on page one for twice as many searches as in the old site's best month.

2.1×page-one results against the old site's best month, last 12 months

0100200old best month = 100202120222023202420252026BEFORE USREFRESH + SEOON SHOPIFYAug 2022 · we startApr 2023 · breach30 Oct 2023 · ShopifyLast 12 months: 2.1× the old best

Teal line: on Shopify, from 30 October 2023

Page-one Google keywords in Canada and the US each month, indexed so the old site's best month (January 2021) = 100. Source: DataForSEO rank history.

09 · South of the border

Search results in the US and Canada

The new store added US shipping and US-dollar pricing. Over the last 12 months, Fratello showed up on page one in the US for 15 times as many searches as before we started, with 6 times as many top-three positions. Canada nearly tripled on both.

  • US · page one15×
  • US · top three6×
  • Canada · page one2.8×
  • Canada · top three2.9×

Aug 2021 – Jul 2022last 12 months

Monthly average of page-one keywords and top-three positions: the year before we started (August 2021 to July 2022) against the last 12 months. Each row is drawn to its own scale.

10 · Regulars

Returning visitors

In the store's first year, returning visitors were 2.3 times as likely to buy as first-timers. They made up about one visitor in six and one order in three.

2.3×as likely to buy, returning against new, first year on Shopify

Share of visitors who bought, returning against new, in the first year after launch (November 2023 to October 2024). Fratello's GA4.

11 · Theirs now

Fratello today

Fratello has changed the type, added yellow, turned rewards into subscriber pricing and moved wholesale ordering into its own system. The store and most of the programs are still the ones we launched in 2023.

See the site ↗

We are getting great leads for wholesale as well, which rarely happened with the old site.

Fratello, one month after launch

We've only had to reach out for a few troubleshooting items since.

Fratello, January 2026
Fratello homepage the week the Shopify store launched
Launch week, October 2023
Fratello homepage today, with 'Subscribers save 20% on every order' across the top
Today